The 5 Best Bivy Sacks for Backpackers

Bivy Sack for Backpackers

I remember the first time I learned about bivy sacks. At Appalachian Trail Days in Damascus, VA someone was telling me about various lightweight shelter options. Bivy sacks came up, naturally, and they intrigued me immediately.

More...

Bivy sacks are tiny little cocoons that protect the hiker and their sleeping bag with almost nothing else for shelter. They’re used by emergency crews, mountaineers, and some extreme athletes who need minimal weight and bulk. That doesn’t mean a bivy sack can’t be for the average Joe hiker, though!

If you’re looking to get away from traditional backcountry shelters, like tents, and into an ultralight fast moving option, bivies might be for you. Fortunately, I’ve spent hundreds of nights on the trail guiding backpacking trips so I can help you compare and contrast these tiny shelters.

Let’s take a deeper look at what bivy sacks are (and are not), who they’re best for, and which bivy sacks make good choices for you.

Comparison Chart

Name

Price

Weight

Rating

Notes

$$$

32 oz

Delrin Single-Pole System

$$$

5.8 oz

A small 5" x 6" Cuben Fiber stuff sack is included in the price and weight

$$$

18 oz

The Helium Bivy is the lightest bivy that Outdoor Research makes

$$$

5.5 oz

The proprietary fabric lets moisture escape at the same time that it keeps rain, snow, and wind on the outside

$$$

12 oz

eVENT fabric foot box (black color) end panel is ergonomically shaped for foot comfort

How to Choose Your Next Bivy Tent

What, exactly, is bivouacking?

Before we dive too deep into the weeds, let’s first make sure we’re all on the same page.

A bivouac, or bivy sack (also: bivy tent), is actually an old word describing a temporary encampment of soldiers made without tents or cover (definition). In fact, the word’s origins are likely deeply Germanic and once referred to a guard or patrol of citizens who protected a town at night!

Today, however, bivouacking refers to the act of camping in a bivy bag. These bivy bags are usually waterproof sleeves that leave just enough room for the sleeper, camping pad, and sleeping bag inside (with breathing room).

Note: I will use various different terms for “bivies” in this article. They all refer to the same thing, I’m just trying to get you used to hearing various terms you may encounter.

Advantages of Bivouacs

Bivy tents have a few major advantages over the “standard” tent.

  • Bivy sacks don’t use rigid poles (usually)
  • Bivy bags are much lighter than your standard tent
  • Bivy tents take up less room in the backpack
  • Bivies can be set up anywhere that there is enough room for you to lay down
  • Bivy bags (usually) don’t need guylines and tent stakes

Disadvantages of Bivouacs

Bivy bags, while they excel in some areas, come with a few major drawbacks. Mostly the drawbacks are concerning their space constraints.

  • Bivy bags can feel claustrophobic
  • Bivy tents don’t have room to sit
  • Bivies don’t have room to change clothes
  • Waterproof bivies tend to collect condensation inside which will get on to your sleeping bag

Who Should Use a Bivy

Alright, first of all, let’s start by saying that I can’t make this decision for you. However, I can lead you to think about when and where bivies usually make sense.

Let’s go over the facts: bivies are lightweight, small, claustrophobic, minimalist shelters.

Unless you have another type of shelter nearby, there’s nowhere to cook out of the wind or rain. There’s nowhere to change your clothes if you might need any privacy.

However, they are about the smallest lightest shelter option available to anyone.

So, if lightweight and minimal bulk are top priorities for you and you can tolerate a claustrophobic shelter with nowhere to do your daily tasks then bivies are perfect.

Many ultralight hikers are more than willing to make these sacrifices for a lightweight shelter though and that’s great!

Just keep in mind that there are some functional drawbacks to bivies as well – not just comfort. Remember that condensation that collects on the inside of your tent during the night? In a bivy that condensation can collect directly on to you and your sleeping bag!

But let’s be real – every type of shelters has pros and cons. So it boils down to deciding if the benefits outweigh the potential drawbacks for you.

Types of Bivy Setups

There’s a lot to know about bivies and how you can use them. In fact, new methods are being pioneered by smart hikers all the time!

For now, though, I’ll explain a couple common methods I know bivy users employ to stay dry and warm.

Bivy With a Tarp

Some hikers use a lightweight bivy underneath a tarp as a bug or water protection layer.

The tarp is your first layer of protection and provides more room to change clothes, eat, or move around without getting soaked. Your bivy adds an extra measure of security, ensuring that you and your sleeping bag or quilt are protected from splash-over and bugs!

Bivy as a Standalone Shelter

Some fully waterproof bivies are used as a standalone shelter. There’s no extra tarp or tent needed – you just put your bag inside the bivy sack and climb in with it.

This method is the most claustrophobic and present logistical problems. For instance – how do you get into your bivy and sleeping bag while it’s raining (and you’re wet) without getting everything soaked?

Bivy Inside a Snow Shelter

For winter touring some people choose to construct snow shelters. By burrowing down into the packed powder, ski tourers and mountaineers can make a group-sized shelter out of the snow itself!

A lightweight bivy can protect the sleeper and sleeping bag from any moisture or melting snow during the night inside a snow shelter.

Types of Bivy Fabric

Nylon

Nylon is used in almost every bivy bag construction. Even waterproof breathable fabrics use a nylon (sometimes polyester) outer layer as an integral part of the construction of the bivy.

Nylon comes in some many weaves, cuts, and variations that you’ll find it called dozens, if not hundreds, of proprietary names. What it boils down to is a water-resistant, windproof (usually) fabric that is highly abrasion resistant.

Polyester

Similar to nylon in many ways, polyester will occasionally see use in bivies. Depending on many factors polyester can be a good competitor to nylon for use in bivies.

Cuben Fiber

Cuben fiber, now called Mylar Composite, is a totally waterproof non-breathable lightweight fabric. Originally used in cutting-edge racing sails, this fabric is made with a layer of Dyneema fibers sandwiched between two layers of plastic called mylar.

When done properly, cuben fiber fabric can be heat welded for a strong, perfectly waterproof seam that uses no sewing. On top of that, it is many orders of magnitude lighter than the closest competitors.

The downfall is that Mylar Composite fabric is not breathable, it’s very expensive, and it’s prone to puncture damage.

Gore-Tex

Goretex Schema

Schematic of a composite Gore-Tex fabric for outdoor clothing

A form of waterproof breathable fabric, Gore-Tex is one of the most popular and proven WPB fabrics available. Gore-Tex I think makes a good choice for those who prefer a reputable brand name and don’t mind paying for the name.

Today there are many different brands of WPB fabric.

eVent

This fabric always makes an appearance on my lists because I love it. Why? It’s a waterproof breathable membrane fabric that has many times the breathability of similar fabrics.

Granted I haven’t seen any research from fabrics this year, but the last I checked, eVent was actually the most “breathable” of all WPB fabrics.

Bivy Bag Weight

Since we’ve already established that bivies can be used in more than one way it stands to reason that they probably vary in weight.

From lightest to heaviest bivies usually fall into this order:

  • Bugnet bivies
  • Windproof/water resistant bivies
  • Dyneema Composite waterproof bivies
  • Waterproof breathable bivies

One factor that will dramatically affect weight is the uses of WPB fabric. This stuff is just heavy but in the case of bivies, it’s one of the only viable options to keep out water without drowning the user in condensation.

Another weight factor is the use of poles to suspend the fabric above the face. This can sometimes be sidestepped by using an elastic shock cord tie-out to pull the fabric up and away instead of a pole.

To compare a tarp+bivy system to a standalone bivy I’ll show you one example of weight:

  • Zpacks Pertex Bivy + UGQ 12×12 Tarp = 29.8 Ounces
  • Outdoor Research Alpine Bivy = 32 Ounces

Of course, a tarp won’t work for all people in all situations. But this goes to show that a tarp, with significant room (12’x12′) plus a bivy, can be as lightweight as just a bivy! And, man, is that extra space nice when it’s raining and you need room to do stuff.

Bulk

Bivies are much less bulky than almost any other shelter type. I mean, they’re pretty much just a cocoon of fabric that’s little bigger than a sleeping bag.

So, what factors can ensure that you keep that low bulk as minimal as possible?

I would say that you need to consider using a quilt instead of a sleeping bag. That will help a lot with minimizing bulk.

On the side of the bivy tent itself, you’ll do best to go with a tarp+bivy to maximize versatility with the least bulk. This also means you can skip the bivy poles and of course, tarps don’t need poles either.

As far as bulk is concerned, there are many ways to reduce bulk in a backpack. Using a bivy is already a step in the right direction and a good bivy is about as minimal as it gets.

Best Bivy Tents for Backpackers

SOL Escape Lite Bivy

If you want a standalone bivy shelter, there are very few out there more robust and well-loved than the OR Alpine Bivy. It’s roomy, waterproof, and can be fully sealed up against wind, rain, or snow.

  • Gore-Tex waterproof breathable
  • Can be staked out
  • Single pole system to keep fabric off your face
  • Weight: 32 Ounces

Let’s be honest, you’d have to be sleeping through a hurricane before water is going to leak into this bivy. The entire thing is made from seam-sealed Gore-Tex and the zippers are covered by flaps that overlap generously to shed water.

You also can set the bivy up using tent stakes or tying out the loops. Plus there’s a single looped pole that provides structure (and breathing room) to the front of the bivy.

Overall this bivy is ideal for a standalone shelter and has enough room for a large pad and high-loft sleeping bag.

ZPacks™ Pertex Quantum Bivy

As a tarp+bivy combination, you’re not going to find a lighter, higher quality bivy than this one. ZPacks is well known for their attention to detail and relentless pursuit of ultralight gear.

  • Waterproof bathtub floor
  • The top zipper can act as a vent
  • Detachable bug screen
  • Weight: 5.8 Ounces

Unlike the OR bivy, the ZPacks bivy uses an elastic cord and a loop to hold the fabric away from your face. This eliminates the need for a pole altogether and lightens the load.

However, let’s be clear that this is not a fully waterproof standalone bivy. It’s ideal for keeping running or splashing groundwater off of you while you sleep under a tarp.

At just 18% of the weight of the Alpine Bivy though this is certainly one of the most ultralight bivy bags for backpackers. Just remember that to compare it to the OR Alpine Bivy you need to factor in the weight of your waterproof tarp as well.

For bug resistance or adding to a tarp, it’s almost impossible to beat this bivy for weight.

For a lightweight standalone bivy, OR took aim directly at the heart of what users need. With some quarreling in the reviews, however, users seem to have mixed experiences.

  • Waterproof/breathable lightweight fabric
  • Overhead pole to add structure
  • Can be staked out
  • Weight: 18 Ounces

Compared to the OR Alpine Bivy, the Helium is indeed lighter by about 44%. That’s thanks to the lightweight Pertex Shield+ fabric which OR claims is highly breathable.

Users seem to find that the bivy has more condensation issues than some other similar bivies though. I’m left wondering if people are using it wrong, or just expecting too much? Fact is, condensation will always be an issue with bivies to some degree.

This bivy can be used fully sealed for waterproof and windproof protection, or you can open the flap near your face to watch the stars through the mesh no-see-um screen.

Overall, I think this is a good lightweight alternative to a standalone bivy system if you can figure out its quirks.

This one is a little less robust than some other options on our list. However, it still makes a great choice for a tarp+bivy option!

  • Water resistant fabric
  • Windproof
  • Reflects body heat radiation
  • Weight: 5.5 Ounces

If you’ve ever seen or used those aluminum survival blankets, you already understand how this works. Instead of a heat reflective plastic, however, this windproof fabric does the same job.

While it’s not technically waterproof, it is highly water resistant and that’s all you need most of the time for underneath a tarp.

Thanks to the lightweight, packable size, and insanely affordable price tag it’s pretty hard to ignore this bivy as a competitor for using in addition to other shelters like a tarp.

It also provides some flexibility to users because during warm months you could use this alone for a summer bag, with a quilt on cold nights, or use just the quilt if the weather is right.

eVent Soul Bivy

Mountain Laurel Designs is a company, like ZPacks, focused on light, fast, and cutting edge. They’re one of the original makers in the space of “ultralight” cottage industry gear, and they remain a great maker.

  • Fully waterproof bivy
  • No way to keep it off your face
  • Made with eVent fabric
  • Weight: 12 Ounces

While Gore-Tex remains the most recognized name in waterproof breathable fabric, the last time I checked eVent fabric actually outperforms Gore-Tex. EVent fabric can release more moisture per square inch than almost any other waterproof breathable material!

While there’s no pole for the face, there is an overhead hang loop which you can use with string or shock cord to keep the fabric off your face.

You can easily open the face to allow some fresh air in with a mesh screen. Plus, near the head of the bivy is some extra space to store a little gear though it won’t be enough for a full backpack.

It’s worth noting that the floor of this bivy is made with Cuben Fiber which is a very lightweight but puncture-prone waterproof material. Some hikers love cuben, others stay away from it due to its high price and potential fragility.


About the author

Casey Fiedler

Professional ski instructor and backpacking guide, Casey Fiedler went to school with CWC and NOLS for Outdoor Education and Leadership. Want to read more about what it takes to lead great adventure trips? Casey writes about outdoor education at caseyfiedler.wordpress.com


Top
Malcare WordPress Security